MoreGehrig: Extensive Gehrig Info Source
Gandolfini Indirectly Disrespects Gehrig
His Career
His Disease
His Family/Personal Life
In His Own Words
His Living Legacy
Little-Known Gehrig Facts
Library o' Gehrig
Shop MoreGehrig
The Memorial Wall
Fan's Tour of Yankee Stadium
Personal Gehrig Stories
Valuable Links
Questions and Answers
MoreGehrig GuestMap
Actor James Gandolfini dampers Gehrig's memory at an ALS charity event

What happened:
On July 4, 1939, Lou Gehrig gave a farewell-to-baseball address from home plate in Yankee Stadium to a crowd of 60,000+. He was being honored that day as no one else in baseball history because he was dying from a lethal and rare disease, ALS. On June 1, 2002, major league ballparks held Project ALS Day in effort to raise money for ALS research. As a marketing gimmick, each park had a celebrity read Gehrig's famous farewell address from home plate. For whatever reason, probably because he's from New York, the Yankees chose The Sopranos star James Gandolfini. What was suppose to be part charity event and part Gehrig tribute turned sour when Gehrig fans got wind of the following Gandolfini words:
"I'm sorry to admit this but I'm not the greatest baseball fan. I'm more basketball and football. But my father is and I got to bring him with me today. I don't know a great deal about Lou Gehrig other than I watched the movie [Pride of the Yankees, assumedly]."

Kaden's take:
To let someone who doesn't have a flea-size amount of knowledge about Gehrig and doesn't even like baseball to begin with stand in the exact spot Gehrig stood reading, weeping and dying more than 60 years prior is unforgivable. To know Lou Gehrig is to know just how agonizing and heart wrenching it was for the reclusive Gehrig to even be the center of attention, let alone to be articulate in front of so many people, to bleed his heart empty despite extreme physical strain and the resulting embarrassment.

I believe Gandolfini would have been a fine choice for, say, Wrigley or even Shea, but not Yankee Stadium. Not one of few shrines this world still has to honor Gehrig. Not when considering that Gehrig's speech is widely thought to be one of the most memorable of the twentieth century. Gandolfini did not respect the magnitude of cherishment baseball/Gehrig fans feel for those words; he did not understand what those words meant to Gehrig.

Gandolfini should have shut up while he had a smidge of respect left from the Gehrig fans, namely this Gehrig fan. He didn't. Observe:

"It [reading Gehrig's speech] connects me with history, being here in the same place. And it's New York. This is New York. You don't get any more New York than this."

Let's review: He goes from ego-centric to geo-centric, never once getting close to something along the lines of, "Happy to do this as a small step in the monstrous battle against ALS and to honor the man I could never rise above even in my dreams."

Sure, the main objective of the day was to raise awareness of ALS, and Gehrig would not have wanted ALS research to take a back seat to him, but at least give him and his words a proper amount of deserved respect.  That's all I ask.

There are at least a few people I can name off the top of my head that would have been a much more reputable choice than Gandolfini to read at Yankee Stadium: Ray Robinson, Yogi Berra, Curt Schilling. And if a twenty-three-year-old kid can think of better people, why in a deity's name couldn't the Yankees think of someone better?

To my new object of distaste, Gando, allow me to say that you don't get any less New York than not being a baseball fan.

And to the marketing wizs at the Stadium, I throw my hot dog wrapper and empty soda cup at you.

Note: Quotes as reported by press.

Written by S. Kaden, 2002